Common misconceptions

Common mistake
Wrong: In the Nernst equation, Q is written with reactants in the numerator and products in the denominator.
Right: Q is written with products in the numerator and reactants in the denominator, exactly as in the equilibrium expression.
Q in the Nernst equation is the same reaction quotient you use in equilibrium chemistry — always products over reactants, based on the cell reaction as written. Students sometimes flip it because they associate 'driving force' with reactants, but that intuition leads to the wrong sign and the wrong answer. If you write Q upside down, a reaction that should slow down (Q > 1) will appear to speed up, which is physically nonsensical.
Common mistake
Wrong: A concentration cell has E°_cell = 0, so it cannot generate any voltage.
Right: A concentration cell has E°_cell = 0 but generates a nonzero EMF via the Nernst equation because Q ≠ 1 when the two half-cell concentrations differ.
E°_cell = 0 simply means both half-cells have identical standard reduction potentials — it says nothing about what happens when concentrations differ. The Nernst equation adds a correction term that depends on Q, and when the two half-cell concentrations are unequal, Q ≠ 1, so the ln Q term is nonzero and the cell generates real voltage. The driving force comes entirely from the concentration gradient, not from a difference in inherent redox chemistry.
Common mistake
Wrong: The Nernst potential for K⁺ is calculated using the intracellular concentration in the numerator.
Right: The Nernst potential uses the ratio of extracellular to intracellular concentration (outside/inside) in the logarithm for a cation, giving the equilibrium potential at which there is no net K⁺ flux.
For a cation like K⁺, the Nernst potential is calculated as E_K = (RT/zF) ln([K⁺]_out / [K⁺]_in). Putting extracellular concentration in the numerator is the convention that gives the correct sign for the equilibrium potential (negative inside for K⁺ under physiological conditions). If you invert the ratio, you get the wrong sign and will predict the wrong direction of ion flux — a critical error when the MCAT asks whether K⁺ is at, above, or below its equilibrium potential.
Common mistake
Wrong: Increasing product concentration increases cell EMF because more product means more reaction has occurred.
Right: Increasing product concentration raises Q, which makes the -ln Q term more negative, thereby decreasing cell EMF.
More product means Q increases, and in the Nernst equation you subtract (RT/nF) ln Q from E°. A larger Q makes ln Q more positive, the subtracted term gets larger, and E drops below E°. Intuitively, accumulated product means the reaction is being pushed back toward equilibrium, reducing the driving force. The cell is running out of steam, not gaining it.
Free Deck audit

See if your Anki deck covers this topic.

Upload your deck →
Guided session

Stuck on this? An AI tutor that probes your understanding.

Start a session →

What the exam tests

  1. Know the Nernst equation (E = E° - (RT/nF) ln Q) and understand what each variable means — particularly that n is the number of electrons transferred in the balanced redox reaction, and Q is always products over reactants.
  2. Calculate or estimate cell EMF when given non-standard ion concentrations, including knowing that at 25°C the RT/F term simplifies so that (RT/nF) ln Q ≈ (0.0592/n) log Q — the form used for quick MCAT calculations.
  3. Explain how a concentration cell generates a nonzero voltage even though E°_cell = 0, and predict which half-cell acts as the anode versus cathode based on which side has lower concentration.
  4. Apply the Nernst equation to calculate equilibrium (Nernst) membrane potentials for K⁺, Na⁺, and Ca²⁺ in neurons or cardiac cells, and interpret what it means when the resting membrane potential differs from the Nernst potential for a specific ion.

Can you avoid these mistakes?

A galvanic cell has E°_cell = +0.34 V and n = 2. If Q = 100 at 25°C, what is the approximate cell potential? Does it increase or decrease from standard, and why?
Two half-cells both contain Cu²⁺/Cu electrodes, but one side has [Cu²⁺] = 0.001 M and the other has [Cu²⁺] = 1.0 M. Which side is the anode? What is E°_cell, and is the cell voltage zero? Explain.
The intracellular [K⁺] is 140 mM and extracellular [K⁺] is 5 mM. Using the Nernst equation at 37°C (RT/F ≈ 26.7 mV), calculate the approximate equilibrium potential for K⁺. Does this match the resting membrane potential (~−70 mV), and what does any difference tell you?
A passage states that in a running electrochemical cell, product ions are accumulating in the cathode compartment. Without doing math, predict what happens to cell EMF over time and identify which term in the Nernst equation is responsible.

Related topics

See how your Anki deck covers this topic.

Upload your deck for a free audit →